Rubio clashes with State Dept. at Cuba hearing
Rubio clashes with State Dept. at Cuba hearing
BY CHRIS ADAMS MCCLATCHY WASHINGTON BUREAU
02/03/2015 1:40 PM 02/03/2015 9:41 PM
Sen. Marco Rubio began an assault on the White House plan to relax
trade, travel and diplomatic restrictions with Cuba, telling top
administration officials Tuesday that he didn’t think it would be
effective and that human rights were being overlooked.
In the first of several congressional hearings on President Barack
Obama’s policy, Rubio laid into the administration. Rubio reiterated his
strong objections, saying he had “deep reservations” about — and “direct
opposition” to — many of the changes being proposed.
He did so, he said, “for the simple reason that I believe that they will
not be effective” in bringing about meaningful change to Cuba.
The West Miami Republican and potential presidential candidate has
emerged as Congress’ chief critic of the new Cuba policy. In a Senate
Foreign Relations subcommittee hearing, Rubio said the opening to Cuba
neglected the reality of human rights abuses on the island.
Rubio, whose parents came from Cuba in 1956, took the reins of the
Western Hemisphere subcommittee as Republicans took control of the
Senate last month.
But other senators were supportive of the new Cuba policy, including
Sens. Barbara Boxer, a Democrat from California, and Jeff Flake, a
Republican from Arizona. Flake said it was time to relax travel
restrictions between the United States and Cuba, something he has pushed
The administration, represented by Roberta S. Jacobson, the assistant
secretary of state for Western Hemisphere affairs, contended during the
hearing that the United States was pursuing the opening with its eyes
wide open, and that it was time to pursue a different strategy from the
one that has failed for a half-century.
“This administration is under no illusions about the continued barriers
to internationally recognized freedoms that remain for the Cuban people,
nor are we under illusions about the nature of the Cuban government,”
said Jacobson, who led the U.S. delegation in last month’s talks in
Havana. “When we sat down with our counterparts in Havana, we were clear
that our governments have both shared interests and sharp differences.”
Ticking off a list of issues over which the two countries are
negotiating, Jacobson said she raised with Cuban officials “our concerns
about its harassment, use of violence and arbitrary detention of Cuban
citizens peacefully expressing their views.”
Rubio and New Jersey Sen. Robert Menendez, a Democrat, are key Senate
opponents to the policy.
In his opening statement, Menendez said that despite the length of the
negotiations between U.S. and Cuban officials, the two sides hadn’t come
up with anything worthwhile.
“Let me be as clear on this issue as I have been since December,” he
said. “Eighteen months of secret negotiations produced a bad deal — bad
for the Cuban people. While it may have been done with the best of
intentions, in my view, we’ve compromised bedrock principles for minimal
He continued: “At the end of the day, 53 political prisoners were
released while so many more remain in jail and the Cuban people — those
who suffered most under the regime — still have zero guarantees for any
The Obama administration’s plans to open the door to Cuba became public
with a dramatic unveiling in December, with the release of USAID
subcontractor Alan Gross and the announcement that trade and travel
restrictions will be eased and that the United States would work to
reestablish diplomatic ties with Cuba.
In his questioning, Rubio drilled into the fact that Jacobson’s office
was not the prime mover on the new Cuba policy. And he wanted to know
which pro-democracy groups in Cuba were consulted.
He also pushed for a declaration from the administration that the
opening of any diplomatic presence, such as a U.S. embassy, wouldn’t
come with restrictions on the ability of embassy personnel to visit
Citing recent public comments from a top Cuban official, Josefina Vidal,
Rubio asked Jacobson whether the United States would ever go forward
with an agreement that — as Vidal indicated — made certain pro-democracy
activists in the country off-limits to embassy personnel.
The United States also limits the travels of Cuban diplomats in the
Vidal actually said during a Cuban Television interview earlier this
week that Cuba was willing to have a discussion about freedom of
movement for embassy personnel but that it was important that the
behavior of U.S. diplomats in Havana change.
She accused them of training, supplying and financing “elements within
our country who act against the interests of the state, the government
and the Cuban people.”
In a back-and-forth with Jacobson, Rubio pressed her for an answer.
Rubio: “Can you say … that under no circumstances will the United States
ever agree to limit the ability of our personnel to interact with
democracy activists … as a condition of expanding our embassy operation?”
“I don’t know if that is a real condition on their part,” said Jacobson,
indicating that Vidal’s remarks may have been more for domestic
consumption in Cuba than the Cuban negotiating position.
But Jacobson said the United States wanted to have the “greatest
possible ability” to interact with people on the island.
Rubio: So we will never agree to limit our personnel?
Jacobson: “We’re going to keep pushing to get those restrictions lifted
as part of getting an embassy…”
Rubio cut her off, saying, “Secretary Jacobson, this is a pretty
straightforward question.” Asked the question again, Jacobson said that
she “can’t imagine that we would go to the next stage of our diplomatic
relationship with an agreement not to see democracy activists, no.”
The hearing also included testimony from Cuban human rights activists,
including Berta Soler, president of the Ladies in White, a Cuban
dissident organization. Speaking through translators, the activists
described the repressive life on the island.
Rubio dominated the hearing, though Flake and others made it clear that
Rubio’s stance faces resistance in Congress. But Rubio and his
Republican allies could crack jokes about their differences.
At one point, after a long reply in Spanish from Soler, Rubio began
talking before the translator had performed her role.
Rubio apologized, saying that he had understood Soler and forgot that
his colleagues in the Senate often couldn’t.
“What I’ve told Sen. Flake is don’t worry about the translation,” Rubio
joked. “I’ll let them know later what they’re saying.”
Miami Herald staff writer Mimi Whitefield contributed to this report.
Source: Rubio clashes with State Dept. at Cuba hearing | The Miami
Herald The Miami Herald –