Alan Gross: Castro's prisoner
We run various sites in defense of human rights and need support to pay for more powerful servers. Thank you.
Archives
Recent Comments

    A Prisoner Swap With Cuba

    A Prisoner Swap With Cuba
    By THE EDITORIAL BOARDNOV. 2, 2014

    Nearly five years ago, authorities in Cuba arrested an American
    government subcontractor, Alan Gross, who was working on a secretive
    program to expand Internet access on the island. At a time when a
    growing number of officials in Washington and Havana are eager to start
    normalizing relations, Mr. Gross’s continued imprisonment has become the
    chief obstacle to a diplomatic breakthrough.

    There is only one plausible way to remove Mr. Gross from an already
    complicated equation. The Obama administration should swap him for three
    convicted Cuban spies who have served more than 16 years in federal prison.

    Officials at the White House are understandably anxious about the
    political fallout of a deal with Havana, given the criticism they faced
    in May after five Taliban prisoners were exchanged for an American
    soldier kidnapped in Afghanistan. The American government, sensibly, is
    averse to negotiating with terrorists or governments that hold United
    States citizens for ransom or political leverage. But in exceptional
    circumstances, it makes sense to do so. The Alan Gross case meets that
    criteria.

    Under the direction of Development Alternatives Inc., which had a
    contract with the United States Agency for International Development,
    Mr. Gross traveled to Havana five times in 2009, posing as a tourist, to
    smuggle communications equipment as part of an effort to provide more
    Cubans with Internet access. The Cuban government, which has long
    protested Washington’s covert pro-democracy initiatives on the island,
    tried and convicted Mr. Gross in 2011, sentencing him to 15 years in
    prison for acts against the integrity of the state.

    Early on in Mr. Gross’s detention, Cuban officials suggested they might
    be willing to free him if Washington put an end to initiatives designed
    to overthrow the Cuban government. After those talks sputtered, the
    Cuban position hardened and it has become clear to American officials
    that the only realistic deal to get Mr. Gross back would involve
    releasing three Cuban spies convicted of federal crimes in Miami in 2001.

    In order to swap prisoners, President Obama would need to commute the
    men’s sentences. Doing so would be justified considering the lengthy
    time they have served, the troubling questions about the fairness of
    their trial, and the potential diplomatic payoff in clearing the way
    toward a new bilateral relationship.

    The spy who matters the most to the Cuban government, Gerardo Hernández,
    is serving two life sentences. Mr. Hernández, the leader of the
    so-called Wasp Network, which infiltrated Cuban exile groups in South
    Florida in the 1990s, was convicted of conspiracy to commit murder.
    Prosecutors accused him of conspiring with authorities in Havana to
    shoot down civilian planes operated by a Cuban exile group that dropped
    leaflets over the island urging Cubans to rise up against their
    government. His four co-defendants, two of whom have been released and
    returned home, were convicted of nonviolent crimes. The two who remain
    imprisoned are due for release relatively soon.

    A three-judge panel on the United States Court of Appeals for the 11th
    Circuit overturned the convictions in August 2005, ruling that a
    “perfect storm” of factors deprived the five defendants of a fair trial.
    The judges found that widespread hostility toward the Cuban government
    in Miami and pretrial publicity that vilified the spies made it
    impossible to impanel an impartial jury. The full court later reversed
    the panel’s finding, reinstating the verdict. But the judges raised
    other concerns about the case that led to a reduction of three of the
    sentences.

    One of the judges, Phyllis Kravitch, wrote a dissenting opinion arguing
    that Mr. Hernández’s murder-conspiracy conviction was unfounded.
    Prosecutors, she argued, failed to establish that Mr. Hernández, who
    provided Havana with information about the flights, had entered into an
    agreement to shoot down the planes in international, as opposed to
    Cuban, airspace. Downing the planes over Cuban airspace, which the
    exiles had penetrated before, would not constitute murder under American
    law.

    Bringing Mr. Hernández home has become a paramount priority for Cuba’s
    president, Raúl Castro. Cuban officials have hailed the men as heroes
    and portrayed their trial as a travesty. Independent entities, including
    a United Nations panel that examines cases of arbitrary detentions and
    Amnesty International, have raised concerns about the fairness of the
    proceedings. The widespread view in Cuba that the spies are victims has,
    unfortunately, emboldened Cuba to use Mr. Gross as a pawn.

    For years, officials in Washington have said that they would not trade
    the Cuban spies for Mr. Gross, arguing that a trade would create a false
    “equivalency.”

    But a prisoner exchange could pave the way toward re-establishing formal
    diplomatic ties, positioning the United States to encourage positive
    change in Cuba through expanded trade, travel opportunities and greater
    contact between Americans and Cubans. Failing to act would maintain a
    50-year cycle of mistrust and acts of sabotage by both sides.

    Beyond the strategic merits of a swap, the administration has a duty to
    do more to get Mr. Gross home. His arrest was the result of a reckless
    strategy in which U.S.A.I.D. has deployed private contractors to perform
    stealthy missions in a police state vehemently opposed to Washington’s
    pro-democracy crusade.

    While in prison, Mr. Gross has lost more than 100 pounds. He is losing
    vision in his right eye. His hips are failing. This June, Mr. Gross’s
    elderly mother died. After he turned 65 in May, Mr. Gross told his loved
    ones that this year would be his last in captivity, warning that he
    intends to kill himself if he is not released soon. His relatives and
    supporters regard that as a serious threat from a desperate, broken man.

    If Alan Gross died in Cuban custody, the prospect of establishing a
    healthier relationship with Cuba would be set back for years. This is an
    entirely avoidable scenario, as Mr. Obama can easily grasp, but time is
    of the essence.

    Source: A Prisoner Swap With Cuba – NYTimes.com –
    http://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/03/opinion/a-prisoner-swap-with-cuba.html?_r=0